Friday, December 18, 2020

List of 36 victims of KyoAni fire listed in credit roll of Violet Evergarden the Movie

(Note: I originally listed the names here, but it did not seem fitting so I moved the names to this separate post.)
 
Last year, there was some controversy in Japan when the names of the deceased from the KyoAni were released to the media. It is a very personal thing, I admit, but I am also torn because I want their memories to be honored. I have added a list of names I found at the end of the post for those who want to know. For those who do not, stop scrolling down.
 
Kyoto Animation 
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
V
-----------------------------------
Below are the names of the deceased which were disclosed last year. They are not in any particular order (okay, they were in some order, first in the time of disclosure, followed by the places they live in, and then in Japanese name order, but I have removed the places of residence). Ages at time of passing away in brackets. There are only 35 names disclosed. The name of the 36th victim, who passed away in October 2019, was not disclosed to the media. All 36 victims were listed. As you can see, anyone who was not directly involved in the production of Violet Evergarden the Movie has been listed in the credit roll as part of the supporting staff. 😢

笠間結花さん (22): Supporting staff
木上益治(三好一郎)さん (61): Supporting staff
津田幸恵さん (41): 仕上
横田圭佑さん (34): 制作マネージャー
栗木亜美さん (30): 原画
宇田淳一さん (34): Supporting staff
大村勇貴さん (23): Supporting staff
武本康弘さん (47): Supporting staff
西屋太志さん (37): Supporting staff
渡辺美希子さん (35): 美術監督
石田奈央美さん (49): Supporting staff
兼尾結実さん (22): 制作マネージャー
川口聖矢さん (27): 原画
草野すみれさん (32): 原画
佐藤綾さん (43): Supporting staff
松浦香奈さん (24): Supporting staff (probably sister of supporting staff 松浦礼奈)
村山(中峰)ちとせさん (49): Supporting staff
森崎志保さん (27): 原画
佐藤宏太さん (28): 原画
武地美穂さん (25): 原画
藤田貴久さん (27): 制作チーフマネージャー
丸子達就さん (31): 作画監督
時盛友樺さん (22): Supporting staff
石田敦志さん (31): Supporting staff
岩崎菜美さん (31): Supporting staff
大當乃里衣さん (26): 仕上
鈴木沙奈さん (30): 原画
高橋博行さん (48): 小物設定、原画
寺脇(池田)晶子さん (44): 原画
松本康二朗さん (25): 制作マネージャー
宮地篤史さん (32): Supporting staff
大野萌さん (21): Supporting staff
西川(壬生)麻衣子さん (29): 原画
明見裕子さん (29): 作画監督
渡辺紗也加さん (27): 原画
浅野杏菜さん (24): 制作マネージャー
 
Related news and articles:

Update 18 July 2024: I updated the list with the name of the 36th victim. This list is complete now.

Thursday, December 17, 2020

Touching scenes in Violet Evergarden the Movie

First, this is not a review. It is just a list of scenes in Violet Evergarden the Movie which made me 😢 or 😭. I am basing this list on my recollection from watching the movie nine times.

Yes, I watched the movie for the ninth time today.
 

Why? Because... yesterday, when I checked the movie schedule for the nearest Dolby Cinema, the movie was no longer on the schedule for this Friday (tomorrow). I thought the movie was ending its run, and went to catch the movie again today... until I realized that the Dolby Cinema I went to will still be showing Violet Evergarden the Movie next week. It is just not on the schedule for this Friday to Sunday (probably to make way for the new movies being released this week).
 

Anyway, if there is a ninth, might as well try for a tenth. 😅

Okay, before I go on, this list is going to be about the movie and may contain spoilers. So for those who haven't watched the movie, you can either hit the back button or close the window, unless you are okay with reading spoilers. Also, the review I wrote can be found here.

|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
V

This is the list of scenes in the movie that made me 😢 or 😭.
 
- Violet saying she should not be praised because she killed many people during the war 😢
- Violet asking Hodgins about what to do about an impossible wish 😢
- Violet telling Diethard that forgetting is impossible 😢
- Violet's excitement about being able to receive some of Gilbert's old toys 😢
- Yuris saying that he will be as cold as Violet's hand before winter 😭
- Violet feeling uncertain before she set off to Ekarte Island 😢
- Violet's letter while on the way to Ekarte Island 😢
- Gilbert expressing his guilt to Hodgins 😭
- Violet telling Gilbert through the door that she understands his guilt 😭
- Yuris telling Iris that he is glad that Violet got to meet Gilbert 😭
- Yuris over the phone and through his letters 😭
- Gilbert reading Violet's letter (voiced by Violet; the last line is not read out) 😭
- The song "Michishirube" playing at the end of the letter 😭
- The fireworks scene when Hodgins looked beside him and Violet was not there 😢
- Daisy's letter to her parents 😢
- Credit roll, knowing that some names are no longer with us 😢
 
There is something wrong with my tear glands. 😅

Kyoto Animation productions in the works as of December 2020

This is just a quick post on upcoming Kyoto Animation productions.
 
We know there will be a sequel to the Sound! Euphonium series featuring Kumiko in her third year of high school and therefore final chance at the nationals. But so far, there is no news on when it will air, and in what form (movie or TV series).

One of the light novels, 『二十世紀電氣目録』, will also be adapted. Similarly, there is little news about this in terms of format and airing date.

A new movie in the Free! series will air in 2021. I have not watched the Free! series before so not much for me to add.
 
Miss Kobayashi's Maid Dragon is getting a second season. It will air in 2021 and the official site is here.
(Picture source: https://maidragon.jp/2nd/)
 
Tsurune will also be getting a sequel movie, but the air date has not been confirmed. Given that the announcement was in October 2020, I think we should be looking at 2022 for the movie to hit the big screen.

If I notice anything else, I will update this post by the end of the year.

Man charged with murder over 2019 Kyoto anime studio arson attack

The man who set fire to Kyoto Animation's 1st Studio has been officially charged with murder (and attempted murder and arson). While this is not going to bring back the dead, I hope it helps the families and injured to find some form of closure, if that is even possible.
 
Below is one of the news reports on this:

I mentioned this when I first watched Violet Evergarden the Movie. Director Yasuhiro Takemoto was one of the names listed in the credits of the movie as a supporting staff. I think many of the 36 who died in the fire were also involved in the movie's production in one way or another, since KyoAni is not a very big production studio. Let me see if I can spot any of their names tonight.

(Note: I originally listed the names at the end of this post, but it did not seem fitting so I move them to a separate post.)

Update 12 May 2023: The dates for the trial have been set.
5 September 2023: First hearing + 9 more session
October 2023: 10 sessions
November 2023: 6 sessions
13 December 2023: Final hearing + 4 sessions before that
25 January 2024: Verdict

Tuesday, December 15, 2020

Watching Violet Evergarden the Movie again (8th time)

Violet Evergarden the Movie has been showing in the theatres for quite a while... in fact, we are now in the 13th week of its showing. I was a bit worried that it will stop showing soon, so I decided to go catch it while I can.
 
And so here I am, watching the movie for the eighth time.
 


When I went to catch the production staff event in Shinjuku, it made me realize the difference between a normal theatre and a Dolby Cinema. Good thing there is a Dolby Cinema nearby (within traveling distance) so I decided to catch the movie there.
 

Before I left for the movie, I checked the online reservation status and saw about 20+ seats reserved. But after the credit roll, I took a look around and saw around 50 to 70 viewers. Guess the movie is still able to draw a crowd.

Still, I don't think it will be showing in theatres much longer. Maybe I should try to catch it again next week... 😅

Anyway, my review of the movie can be found here. I update my review and other relevant posts as and when I notice something new, such as when I watch the movie again...

Update: The nearby Dolby Cinema will only be showing the movie until this Thursday. Which is tomorrow! 😱
Update 2: Stupid me... the show is still showing next week at the nearby Dolby Cinema. It just so happens that it is giving way to newer shows for the weekend, that is all.

Monday, December 14, 2020

The dog stuffed toy in Violet Evergarden

In the Violet Evergarden TV series, Violet chose the dog stuffed toy because Diethard called her Gilbert's dog. The dog symbolises Violet, and you can see it in her room at the postal company.
 

I think its location represents Violet's home. Which is why you see it in her room. But you never see it in her travels. She does not carry it around with her. In the movie, it was facing the window, looking out of it. As if it was a real dog looking out of the window, watching to see if it can see its master coming home.

And that is why it is so symbolic that she brought the dog stuffed toy with her in the final cut after the credit roll of Violet Evergarden the Movie. Basically, it means she has moved in with Gilbert, and Gilbert's home is now hers too.
 

Someone make me this stuffed toy please. 😅


My review of the movie can be found here.

断肠崖 (a place from Return of the Condor Heroes)

"十六年后,在此相会,夫妻情深,勿失信约。"
"小龙女书嘱夫君杨郎,珍重万千,务求相聚。"

According to Baidu,
"断肠崖上叹绝情,绝情谷底哭断肠"

Platinum Preppy fountain pens

Just to share. I bought this set of 7 fountain pens in various colors (black, blue black, red, pink, violet, yellow, and green; Platinum Preppy, model number PSQ-300) recently because it was on offer on Amazon. The nibs are 0.3 but I think they also come in 0.2 and 0.5 but with a smaller range of colors.
 
Given that each is a 300 yen fountain pen, I really did not expect much from then. But when I gave one a test, it wrote exceptionally well for its price. Wow!

By the way, these fountain pens do not come with a converter, but they are sold with an ink cartridge of their corresponding color each. They use Platinum's own ink cartridges, but you can also get a Platinum converter for them, though the converter is about 500 yen and is therefore more expensive than the pen itself. Ink cartridges are 100 yen for a pair here in Japan.

For those who are interested, here is an affiliate link to Amazon.com. (They are slightly cheaper in Japan.)


Friday, December 11, 2020

Playing audio file from Google Drive on Blogger

Blogger allows you to upload pictures and videos to blogs, but not audio files. But there is a way to do this, although it can be a bit "manual". The main idea is to find a place that can host your audio file, then use the HTML audio tag to play that file.

In my case, I want to host the file on Google Drive. But the link provided by Google Drive does not work with the audio tag, at least not directly.

I have been teaching myself to play the Chinese traverse flute. A few days ago, I started trying to learn to play "Michishirube". I made a short recording, and I will use that here as an example.

First, after recording the audio file, upload it to Google Drive. Then, on Google Drive, right click on the file, choose "Get link". Then set to "Anyone with the link" to allow the link to be accessed. The link looks like this.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Fy_lOSoYHSz8WQhTzzQVTj8DniFZisEI/view?usp=sharing
The part that is needed is the file ID, which in this case, is
1Fy_lOSoYHSz8WQhTzzQVTj8DniFZisEI
 
Then, in Blogger, switch to HTML view to add the audio tag. This is how it usually looks like
<audio controls="controls" src="https:// link to file">
</audio>

However, you cannot use the Google Drive link directly. The link that works with the audio tag looks like this:
https://docs.google.com/uc?export=download&id=fileID
where fileID is the one mentioned above.
 
So in my case, the final tag looks like this:
<audio controls="controls" src="https://docs.google.com/uc?export=download&id=1Fy_lOSoYHSz8WQhTzzQVTj8DniFZisEI">
</audio>

 
Hope this helps!


Update 14 July 2024: The above method does not seem to work anymore.

Tuesday, December 08, 2020

The limits of our current machine learning concept

First, to be clear, I am not talking about the actual machine learning techniques and models like RNN, CNN, LSTM, and such. Rather, I am talking about the bigger concept being machine learning (including deep learning) in general.

Our current concept of machine learning involves training a model based on some set of data. There is a "ground truth" in the training process. This is not a problem when trying to differentiate between a cat and a dog, or to recognize the letters of the English alphabet. These data sets have distinct and discrete categories.

But our world is not all black and white.

For example, a matchmaking app that uses past data of couples to recommend potential partners. Based on a list of attributes, the model learns what kind of people pair up. It then uses that model to recommend partners to singles. But to the person receiving the recommendation, is this the partner that he or she really wants? What if the model has not taken into account certain attributes? What if the model has assigned weights that are actually different from the target person's? After all, each person is unique, and the attribute space can be extremely large if we keep breaking it down.
 
What happens when our choices become those recommended by a machine? Instead of opening up our options, are we instead confining them to whatever is the limit of the model being used by the machine? Instead of fitting training data to a model, will we end up fitting humanity to a model's limited data space?

This question is always there in the realm of what we call the arts. The non-technical part of our lives. This includes language, which is a major realm of machine learning research. Two main areas are research in machine translation and text generation. But... there is no "right" answer in these realms. "I love you" can be translated as "愛している", but it can also be "月がきれいですね" if you really consider the entire cultural and literary context. But we are creating models that come up with the "right" answers, which in such cases, usually means selecting the best out of several possibilities. Eventually, as we keep selecting a single "right" answer, will we end up reinforcing the model to narrow its selection to that single "right" answer? Will we enter a self-fulfilling reinforcement loop that actually narrows our options, our creativity? Will we end up with translated texts that follow a certain style and uses only certain words and expressions? Will we end up generating texts that follow a certain fixed pattern?

And language shapes the way we think. We can have great ideas, but we can only express them, communicate them to others, through words. The words we can use, then, naturally limits what we can express. We can think, but a thought that cannot be manifested in the physical world remains confined within our own. Will our reliance on AI in the realm of language end up limiting the human mind?

As the character John Keating said in the movie Dead Poets Society, "We don't read and write poetry because it's cute. We read and write poetry because we are members of the human race. And the human race is filled with passion. And medicine, law, business, engineering, these are noble pursuits and necessary to sustain life. But poetry, beauty, romance, love, these are what we stay alive for."

Will our reliance on AI end up sustaining life but not make it worth living for?

79th anniversary of attack on Pearl Harbor

Pearl Harbor, 79 years later.


Each day, there are fewer people who can talk about their experiences of the war.

Monday, December 07, 2020

Violet Evergarden the Movie is a story about guilt

No one can be wrong to call the Violet Evergarden series as a story about love. Of course, I think it is about love not in the narrow sense of romantic love, but in the broader sense of love between two persons spanning a variety of relationships. The entire series (one TV series and two movies) portray a wider range of human emotions than the romantic love between two persons.

But the theme of guilt is also very prominently featured in Violet Evergarden the Movie. Gilbert's guilt for using Violet as a tool of war was part of the story in the original light novel, but because Gilbert was not featured heavily in the TV series, the theme of guilt only came to be prominently featured this time in the movie, when Gilbert becomes one of the key characters. (There is also Diethard's guilt about pushing everything, like carrying on the family traditional, to Gilbert.)

(Picture source: Violet Evergarden official Twitter)

We have all done things which makes us feel guilty. It is how we deal with guilt that differs from person to person. Some are able to put it aside, some continue to dwell over it. And sometimes, it helps to have someone else, something else, to be an impetus for accepting guilt. To accept that the past cannot be changed, but our own choices and actions can make a difference in the future.

This was touched on in the TV series, when Violet eventually realizes that her actions during the war had resulted in so many deaths which cannot be undone. But her colleagues at C.H. Postal Company helped her overcome that guilt, helping her to realize that the people she had killed will no longer return to life, but her actions today and tomorrow will help change the lives of others.

I think this experience was what helped Violet understand Gilbert's guilt. She understood that Gilbert feels guilt for using her as a tool of war, for being the cause of her guilt. In turn, she is the cause of his guilt. And because she understood that they are the cause of each other's guilt, she convinced herself that Gilbert was right, and they should not be together. Both Gilbert, who is very good at being rational and controlling his emotions from his life in the army, and Violet allowed their rational minds to suppress their emotional hearts.
 
(Picture source: Violet Evergarden official Twitter)

Which makes their reunion all the more dramatic. Since it is the emotional hearts who managed to break through the rational minds. It shows the depth of their love for each other, a love so strong it can overcome the guilt of being the cause of each other's guilt.
 

(Picture source: Violet Evergarden official Twitter)

Daisy also learnt how to deal with her guilt for always being so harsh on her mother. Yuris finally dealt with his guilt for treating his friend so coldly. Daisy learnt to do so through her journey in pursuit of Violet. Yuris learnt to do so based on the advice from Violet.

Sometimes, all we need is someone or something to help us deal with guilt.

(I realized that I have been writing so much about Violet Evergarden, I decided to create a label for posts related to the Violet Evergarden series. But I can't really say I am a fan of the series, since I know of someone who has watched the movie 57 times as of December 4, 2020... 57 times in less than three months since the movie started showing in cinemas.)

My overall thoughts on Violet Evergarden The Movie

Events:
 
Translations of short stories:
Gilbert Bougainvillea and the Fleeting Dream (unofficial translation of "ギルベルト・ブーゲンビリアと儚い夢")
The Starry Night and the Lonely Two (unofficial translation of 星降りの夜とさみしいふたり)
Diethard Bougainvillea's If (unofficial translation of ディートフリート・ブーゲンビリアIf) 
The Tailor and the Auto-Memories Doll (unofficial translation of 仕立て屋と自動手記人形)
 
Tellsis (Nunkish) translation:
Last line of Violet's final letter to Gilbert
 
Insights on the movie:
 
Audio commentary notes:
 
 
All posts related to Violet Evergarden.

Friday, December 04, 2020

Letter of appreciation from Violet Evergarden's author Akatsuki Kana

This is the letter from author Akatsuki Kana to fans, a part of which was read out during the recent talk event.


I have taken the liberty to translate it into English for fans.
---------------------------------------------------
Thank you for watching Violet Evergarden the Movie.
C.H. Postal Company will be delivering this letter after it is sealed. I hope it arrives safely. It is snowing now in this northern part of the world, and I am worried the letter may get wet and cannot be read. Still, it is an experienced postman that I am handing this letter to, so things should be fine.

I am surprised to hear that so many people have been watching the movie. I am really happy. Thank you! It seems that this movie has become a part of the viewers' lives.

Watching a movie is an experience and takes up the precious time of viewers. Traveling to a cinema, and watching the names of the production staff on the credit roll. It may be easy to write with words, but it is actually not that simple.

And for it to be a long running hit, this can only be achieved by the chain reaction of viewers. It is a miracle that only happens after viewers gradually spread the word around, telling others "It was a good movie" and "Watch it and tell me what you think."

Thank you for this chain of kindness. I offer my utmost gratitude to you...

... Sorry, I really want to write more words of appreciation, but the postman from C.H. Postal Company is looking over my shoulder at the letter while he waits.
... He just told me it is almost time and I need to seal the letter. He is impatient and I want to let him go back on time, so I shall end the letter here.

But just one final word. I hope the wonderful moment that happened to Violet will also occur in your life.

Sincerely,
Akatsuki Kana

Production staff event at screening of Violet Evergarden the Movie

Update 21 Dec, 2020: Official report from Kyoto Animation on this event has been released.
The official report is not a full transcript. For example, it does not report the part about Evan Call getting his then-girlfriend (now-wife) to help him read the novel. Director Ishidate also mentioned during the event that he forgot to mention the issue of 3D modeling of Leiden during the previous event, when the 3D staff was present.
In the official report, as an afternote, Suzuki confirmed that the written words in Violet's word were first translated from the original Japanese to English, then from English to another language (not specified, but we know it is Tamil), and finally, some of the more common letters are swapped. 
----------------------------------
 
After watching Violet Evergarden the Movie six times, the other day, Kyoto Animation announced that there will be a event on December 3, 2020 where the production staff will talk about behind-the-scenes of the entire series.

This is a good reason to catch the movie a seventh time.


As luck would have it, December 3, 2020 is also the day when the movie opens back home in Singapore, so in a way, I was watching the same movie as fans back home.

The last time I watched the movie was at a Dolby Cinema, and my oh my, it made me realize the difference when I watched the movie again at a normal cinema. The colors aren't as vibrant, the images aren't as sharp, and the sound not as defined. However, I was still weeping throughout the movie. Some things don't change.

The screening was followed by the production staff coming on stage to talk about behind-the-scenes episodes about the entire series.

 
Director Ishidate Taichi, composer Evan Call, world concept Suzuki Takaaki, producer Hatta Shinichiro, and music producer Saito Shigeru were the ones at the event today. Music producer Saito played the role of MC to drive the event, asking questions to the other four as well as reading out prepared comments from screenplay writer Yoshida Reiko and author Akatsuki Kana.

It started with director Ishidate talking about how impressed with the original work. He and producer Hatta were both on the judging panel for the Kyoto Animation Award, and director Ishidate gave the work top score and a double endorsement, as if trying to tell the rest that he wants to be the one directing if the work is made into an anime. Producer Hatta said he recalled it was like an unanimous decision that Violet Evergarden would get the Grand Prize. He also mentioned that director Ishidate had to rewrite the anime proposal a few times because they sounded more like reviews of the work rather than a proper proposal. They also mentioned that the series was planned for an international audience from the start. They felt the setting and story would appeal to people outside Japan too, so they started by allowing people to freely propose songs for the commercial. This eventually resulted in the song Violet Snow, and the commercial that ended with "The anime project is in the works" in eight languages.

Director Ishidate revealed that it was screenplay writer Yoshida Reiko who came up with the idea to sequence the anime series in a way that introduces Violet and how she became an Auto Memories Doll. The light novel starts with Violet already an established Doll, but Yoshida felt there is a need to properly introduce viewers to this idea. Director Ishidate was originally against the idea because he loved the original work, but I guess we should be glad that Yoshida got her way.

Next up was world concept Suzuki Takaaki's involvement. Yoshida roped him in to help with the world concept, and he was actually quite surprised to be working with Kyoto Animation. You can see the pains he went to... they showed a few of the concepts he drew up, including a map of the continent with the climates of each region, the locations of key cities, and even their average temperatures and when the rainy season starts... wow. He also had to design a map of Leiden, and the map eventually ended with almost every street having its own name. Director Ishidate even got the 3D modeling staff to turn the map into a full 3D model. Which was used only ONCE in the anime (during Episode 1). He said he is sorry for making the 3D staff do all that work but only using the model once... but that 3D model helped them visualize the stories they are trying to write and portray, so it was a useful production tool. Suzuki also mentioned that EVERY book, letter, newspaper, etc. in the anime can be decoded. Including the books that were used by Gilbert to teach Violet to read. And I guess that means the books on the sea that Violet used in writing the poem for the sea festival shown in the movie.

Then the topic went to music, and music producer Saito talked about how they made the song Violet Snow. Composer Evan Call was roped in a bit later, just before they did the second commercial for the light novels. Evan said he wanted to impress the staff by bringing a music piece with him on the first meeting, so he had to read the novel. Which was difficult because it was a book, not in digital form (which can be voiced using text-to-speech software), so he struggled with the kanji characters. He got his then-girlfriend (now wife) to help him read the novel, which he managed to finish halfway before he needed to work on the music for the meeting. The first piece he created was the theme which eventually became used for the commercial as well as the anime series as the main theme. Evan also mentioned that the music for the anime was recorded in a studio in Tokyo, which was adequate for a TV series, but lack the depth for a theater screening. So the music for the movie was recorded in Germany, which has huge studios that allow recording of music with the right amount of depth.

The staff also talked about visiting locations for ideas. Suzuki felt that a European setting was perfect for the story, but Ishidate and Yoshida felt there should be some Oriental element to it. Plus a European setting won't really work for Leiden, which is in the south and European buildings would be ovens in that climate. So he designed Leiden with a more colonial look--European-style buildings with larger windows for the hotter climate. They visited Hokkaido which has quite some buildings in such a style. They also talked about visiting Germany for inspiration. During their visit to Germany, the script for the Gaiden movie had already been written and they used that trip to get inspiration for that too, such as the setting for the dance scene. The impression I got was that the entire series--TV anime, Gaiden movie, and the finale movie--was all planned out even before the TV series aired.

It was also mentioned that in the first commercial, the typewriter was drawn and animated by hand. The entire thing (which was like a second or two of time) took the artist (the best at KyoAni) an entire month. That was when director Ishidate decided that the typewriter should be done in 3D instead.

Saito also read out a comment from Yoshida thanking fans for their support, and an excerpt of a letter from author Akatsuki Kana. The full letter was released on Twitter and the movie's official site. My translation of the letter can be found here.


The event ended with an announcement that there will be a live concert in Omiya on February 6, 2021.
 
I am glad I made my way to this event. I had attended the first cast greeting event as well as the second one, but both were live broadcasts (viewed at the local theater) of the actual events in Kyoto. I didn't manage to go for the third event, which was also in Kyoto but not broadcast live. This time, the event (fourth one) was slightly nearer (in Shinjuku, Tokyo) so it was within reasonable travel distance. Yes, it was more than an hour away by train, and yes, I got back after midnight, but I am really glad I went.

Now to wait for the Blu-ray release... and probably get a 4K TV too. 😅

By the way, director Ishidate did not talk about the last line of Violet's final letter to Gilbert, but I think that was because he already gave the answer at the previous event in Kyoto.

My overall thoughts on Violet Evergarden The Movie

Events:
 
Translations of short stories:
Gilbert Bougainvillea and the Fleeting Dream (unofficial translation of "ギルベルト・ブーゲンビリアと儚い夢")
The Starry Night and the Lonely Two (unofficial translation of 星降りの夜とさみしいふたり)
Diethard Bougainvillea's If (unofficial translation of ディートフリート・ブーゲンビリアIf) 
The Tailor and the Auto-Memories Doll (unofficial translation of 仕立て屋と自動手記人形)
Laura and the Auto-Memories Doll (unofficial translation of ローラと自動手記人形)
Flowers and the Auto-Memories Doll (unofficial translation of 花と自動手記人形)
 
Tellsis (Nunkish) translation:
Last line of Violet's final letter to Gilbert
 
Insights on the movie:
 
Audio commentary notes:
 
 
All posts related to Violet Evergarden.

Tuesday, December 01, 2020

Violet Evergarden's background in the light novel

The first meeting between Violet Evergarden and Major Gilbert Bougainvillea is described in the last chapter of volume one of the Violet Evergarden light novel.
 
(Picture source: Violet Evergarden Wikia)

The anime series did not really expand a lot on how Gilbert's brother, Diethard, came upon Violet and subsequently gave her to Gilbert. It focused more on what happened after that.

In the light novel, Diethard found Violet on a deserted island after his ship ran aground. He and his men were surprised to see a young girl on the island, and when one of his men tried to rape Violet, she killed him. This surprised Diethard even more, and when Diethard ordered all his men to kill her, Violet mistook it as an order for her to kill all his men. Which she proceeded to do. In the end, Diethard was stranded alone with Violet on the island, who followed him as if waiting for her next order. It seemed she did not understand words, but somehow understood the word "kill". When he eventually made his way back, he brought her with him. Diethard kept her close because she seemed to listen to his orders, and he was afraid of her. Afraid of what she might do if he was not the one giving orders. He also mentioned that so far, eight men have died trying to get in her bed.
 
Diethard gave Violet to Gilbert as a gift to celebrate Gilbert being promoted to major. Well, at least that was what he said. But it was actually because Gilbert was afraid of handling Violet, and wanted to be rid of her. Violet was probably around 10 years old at that time; Diethard mentioned that he can't really handle things once she grows older and starts having her period and stuff. At that time, Gilbert was 25 years old (the light novel mentioned he started fighting when 17 years old, and had been in campaigns since then for 8 years). I guess that means they are about 15 years apart in age.
 
Gilbert took over Violet from Diethard because he was partly not happy with how his older brother treated the young girl so roughly. At the same time, he sensed that his brother was truly afraid of Violet. He himself saw Violet kill five men (in a mini demo staged by Diethard when he presented Violet to Gilbert). Gilbert was also afraid of what might happen if he passed Violet to someone else; his brother had warned him that putting Violet in an orphanage may end up with a bloodbath at the orphanage, given the killing machine that she was. In the end, he decided that the best way to make sure Violet is cared for without endangering others is to keep Violet with him. And the only way to do that while he is fighting a war is to find a way to enroll Violet into the army.
 
To convince his army superiors to allow a young girl into his unit, he got them to allow him to stage a demonstration of Violet's fighting prowess. Hodgins met Violet for the first time just before the demonstration was to start and witnessed the entire thing. Violet killed 10 men in the demonstration, stunning everyone watching the demonstration. Two things were clear: she is highly skilled in killing, and she only listens to orders from Gilbert. Gilbert's superiors in the army decided to give Gilbert his own special forces unit, for the purpose of employing the "weapon" that he has. On the night before the unit was to set off on its first expedition, Gilbert named the "weapon" Violet, after the goddess of a flower which appeared in myths. It was here that Violet spoke her first word: major (Gilbert's rank). Also, Violet was never officially enrolled in the army. She was categorised as a weapon, to be used by Gilbert.
(Note: I have been trying to find this reference about the goddess. The flower violet is associated with Ares and Aphrodite. I guess Gilbert may be drawing reference to Aphrodite, the goddess of love and beauty, and not Ares the god of war. But it would be a fitting reference both ways. The beauty of Aphrodite, and the destruction of Ares. If anyone knows a more fitting goddess and myth for this reference, please leave a comment!)

After the war, the Evergarden family took Violet in, and she lives with them in their mansion while commuting to work at C.H. Postal Company.

Consolidating the key facts:
- Violet was living alone on a deserted island.
- Violet was around 10 years old when Diethard found her and eventually gave her to Gilbert.
- Gilbert was 25 years old when he was given Violet.
- Gilbert took Violet in to both make sure she is looked after as well as to make sure she does not endanger others.
- Violet was a killing machine, having killed five men in close combat during the "demonstration" staged by Diethard and 10 men in the "demonstration" staged by Gilbert.
- The first word that Violet is known to have uttered is "major".

As you can see, this background can be slightly (at the very least) problematic if it was actually adapted into anime. I am really glad KyoAni decided to make changes to the story for the anime adaptation. The light novel makes for great reading, but certain scenes are better left as words than visuals.


Note: As I am still reading the light novels, this post will be updated as and when I happen upon more information.

Side note: Hodgins remained a major at the end of the war. I wonder why KyoAni promoted him to lieutenant colonel in the anime adaptation.